Bound to Respect: the Dred Scott Incident

Essay details

Please note! This essay has been submitted by a student.

Download PDF

In W.E.B. DuBois’s Of Our Spiritual Strivings and Walter Johnson’s No Rights Which the White Man Is Bound to Respect, the theme of “being a problem” or “being a burden” is recurring it is very hard to shake. Your sense of identity really takes a toll on you, whether you realize it or not. Comparing the two articles, the theme of their sense of self identity was tested every single day. African Americans constantly felt like aliens not just back then, but it is still evident in today’s world and will likely never be without it. The slavery aspect is not the remnant of the past, as it would seem, but the fact that it is our horrifying present.

Essay due? We'll write it for you!

Any subject

Min. 3-hour delivery

Pay if satisfied

Get your price

The term “self-identity” by definition means the recognition of one’s potential and qualities as an individual, especially in relation to social context. Picking endlessly at the readings, I presumed that self character is made out of generally changeless self-appraisals, for example, individual qualities, information on one’s aptitudes and capacities, one’s occupation and diversions, and familiarity with one’s physical traits. Each person has a unique view of the world and the people around them. A great amount of people don’t have an unmistakable or cognizant comprehension of what the world really is and how they build up their self-personality while experiencing this world.

From 1833 to 1843, Dred Scott dwelled in Illinois and in the Louisiana Territory where subjection was restricted in all perspectives by the Missouri Compromise of 1820. In the scandalous instance of Dred Scott v. Sandford, which was contended in 1856 through 1857, the Supreme Court went to the decision that Americans of the African decent, free or slave, are not viewed as American residents, and in this way people could not sue in the government court. Furthermore, the Court likewise decided that Congress did not have the ability to boycott servitude in any U.S. domain. He then returned to his home state, Missouri. Right after arriving home, Scott filed a lawsuit in the Missouri court for his freedom. He strongly claimed that his residence in the Louisiana Territory, a free territory, made him a completely free man. Unfortunately, Scott’s master maintained the no descendant of slaves could be a citizen according to Article III of the Constitution.

While investigating this thesis further, it is easy to notice the racism evident in the past and most definitely still here in today’s world and how oddly normal this was. Sedimentary hints of socially built information about race and whiteness have been archived in America’s history of subjection, Jim Crow, isolation, and segregation dependent on the credit of some proportion of social downgrading forced on non-white people groups and normatively characterized as racial qualities. Under these conditions, one could contend that various Americans have been unfavorably affected by ‘bias by desires.’ Racism by reason works at the level of the individual and is showed as racial inclination and division toward non-white people. In other words, having low expectations of minorities in schools and other forms of achievement is of normal bigotry in these days. While being told this every day, the minorities all over the world began evolving their sense of identity in what other people engraved in their brain all of these years. This contradiction looks consequences of ‘fanaticism by plan.’ I examined how much bias is evident in today’s world because of this racial tension throughout the world. Such a middle reveals, that the idea and start of whiteness gets from the components of partiality by desire, a kind of bias that is built up upon custom and show, yet breaks against social intelligent measures.Throughout the passages and reports, the author and people discussed throughout unintentionally show their sense of self-identity. In Walter Johnson’s report, No Rights Which the White Man Is Bound to Respect, Johnson provides a quote from Taney that set the minorities sense of self-identity for them. By going against everything that was right and just in the courtroom, Taney finished up and announced that they had no rights by any stretch of the imagination. Despite what might be expected, he contended they were of a mediocre request and inside and out unfit to connect with the white race, regardless of whether in social or political relations, thus far sub-par that they had no rights which the white man will undoubtedly regard. Those last 10 words go down in history as being the 10 most notorious words in history. Those words were undoubtedly degrading the African American race. They unwillingly stuck with those words throughout history and continue to carry that idea that Taney made for them.

Believe it or not, the minorities from this time period never had the chance to develop their own sense of self, it was always engraved into their brains for them by other people that have absolutely no right or space to make that for them. Although these passages are mostly set years ago, there was an abundant amount of discrimination and racism being directed towards the African Americans every single place they went. It is extremely scary to see how much racism and discrimination is being dragged back in today’s world, whether we notice it or not. The fact that we do not consider the implicit ways racism slithers its way in everyday interactions, including in our professional environments, is becoming more of a norm in today’s society. Instances in schools have been increasingly part of our culture, “while students chant “Build the wall,” “White power,” and “Heil Hilter,” (Vogel 1), they are directly targeting the miniority group. Minority groups are tested every single day and their self of sense identity becomes more and more negative throughout their lives of being constantly targeted and verbally or sometimes physically abused. They start to believe the atrocious thoughts that white people are putting in their head and believe that they are “worthless” and “trash.”

As indicated by Walter Johnson, The Dred Scott choice viably contended that dark individuals lived in Missouri by the finesse of white individuals. It clarified that there would be no legitimate point of confinement to what white individuals may do to them, exclusively or as the nearby or state government. Anybody being engaged with the wrongdoings against minorities and any other person around are viewed as unfortunate enough to stand close by. This chillingly speaks to a startling picture of the world to come, for our minorities, however a general public overall. Also, presently what I have quickly portrayed in somewhat of a blueprint showed from numerous points of view, with cherishing accentuation and more profound detail, that men may tune into the spirits of dark people.

Get quality help now


Verified writer

Proficient in: Dred Scott v. Sandford

4.8 (345 reviews)
“Writer-Justin was a very nice and great writer. He asked questioned as necessary to perform the job at the highest level. ”

+75 relevant experts are online

banner clock
Clock is ticking and inspiration doesn't come?
We`ll do boring work for you. No plagiarism guarantee. Deadline from 3 hours.

We use cookies to offer you the best experience. By continuing, we’ll assume you agree with our Cookies policy.